Apple's iPad: Still looking for a use-case

This post was written on 2010/01/31 at 01:21:19 by Horst Gutmann

Steve Jobs did it again and announced a device, many people think will change the world. Well, I for one am still wondering what kind of use I might have for it. A few years ago while still working at University projects I had the chance to play around a little bit with a tablet PC running Windows XP and it was barely usable for what I wanted to do with it. Granted, Apple has done some miracles with the iPhone user interface, but what would I want to have mostly the same in 9.7" device without any real benefit?

Those 9.7" are beyond the sweet-spot where you don't need a separate bag (which I don't really mind) but already close enough to an area where I'd use a netbook. Since I can't see myself using an iPad somewhere in a metro to read stuff (compared to my iPhone or a definitely smaller eBook reader or [oh shock] a classic book), a netbook would do basically the same for me as that new wondrous device out of Cupertino.

During the keynotes Steve Jobs said that the new device must be better at a handful of key features than a laptop and an iPhone: browsing, email, photos, video, music, games and eBooks. He also said, that Netbooks don't apply here, since they don't do anything out of these better than a laptop. Well, so for me, neither does the iPad with the exception of eBooks. The difference here is, that with a laptop I can actually manipulate all that content, with the iPad as with the iPhone I get the feeling, it might only be good at viewing that content. 

Jeff Gerstmann over at Giantbomb also mentioned something that kind of confused me during the Steve Notes:

It's a shame that Apple chose to show off a driving game (Need for Speed Shift) and a first-person shooter (Gameloft's NOVA), because those are perfect examples of what not to do on a platform without standard controls.

It's really weird why Apple always chooses racing games when showing off games for their handheld devices when games Star Defense or even simpler games work way better.

Don't get me wrong: Technologically this device is probably really nice and it was a total surprise to see it using a custom made chip, but I don't see it doing anything for me yet. The book store would have been a really nice feature but for now I'll probably just sit and wait and hopefully see it doing to the whole book world what iTunes did to the world of online music ... so I don't mean hardcover prices, thank you. But for now, the iPad had to prevail in a fight with a netbook about space in my bag, a fight it can't really win right now. Also, because it doesn't even have standard USB ports to get photos onto it directly from a camera.

For home-use, the story looks a bit different since there I already have my laptop sitting on the table and might want to use something like the iPad while relaxing on the couch. Not something worth 500USD on, to be honest, but perhaps there might be something in the future that might change my opinion on this device ;-)

Again, what if all you want is a content device on your couch? Or if you don't need such a device to work with? Then the iPad is probably a really nice idea. Daniel Tenner described it as "tailored to those people who don't actually need a computer". So I'm simply not even remotely close to the target audience, it seems ;-)

P.S.: I'm also really disappointed that there was no new iWorks and iLife announced. I've been holding off updating my parents' Mac for quite some time now and waited right for this event :-(

Comments:

  • Daniel Hoelbling (Guest)

    Well the iPad is also a complete failure for me, but my list of problems looks a bit different.

    I could (theoretically) overlook lack of multi-tasking, but having the tablet not support Flash is a complete killer.

    The only real use case I was seeing for this was my couch. A casual way to read up on magazines, news etc. Without having flash on the device I am not only missing out on 100% of all embedded videos (and they are not all YouTube mind you) but also on many good Apps that I use.

    Since I already own a Sony eBook reader, I don't ever see myself turning to a IPS display to read something. eInk is way sharper und much more comfortable on the eyes than ANY other screen device out there.

    Using this thing to watch Videos is also kind of silly, since my couch is 5 feet away from a nice 37" TV set that I could equip with a very nice Windows Media Center PC for the same price as the iPad, delivering a lot more utility than the iPad.

    Well, and that's it. I don't see any other use-cases for this. On the go it has no real use neither as a note-taking thingy nor as anything else. That space in my Bag is either used by a real work-device, or I don't carry a bag at all so I'd use my Phone..

    Also, just to be honest here: Besides flash support I really feel this lacks multi-tasking and some serious connectivity (I mean SD-Cards, USB, HDMI etc).

    greetings Daniel

    Jan. 31, 2010, 10:08 a.m.

*'d input fields are required.